Why this matters...
Anyone can say “New York–style pizza.” What actually matters is how the pizza eats.
A real New York slice should be thin, crisp on the bottom, chewy inside, and strong enough to fold without cracking. That doesn’t happen by accident — it comes from dough, fermentation, and baking technique done the same way every day.
That’s the standard we build everything around.
“Fresh Dough Made Daily — Stone-Fired NY-Style Pizza”
> “Real New York pizza — every single day.”
> “The best Sicilian in Tampa Bay.”
> “Fresh dough daily, stone-fired, never reheated.”
> “Real NY-style slices. Legendary Sicilian. Total consistency.”
Order Pickup or Delivery
*Creative Loafing
“Best Pizza in Tampa”
*Tampa Bay Times
“Best Pizza in Tampa Bay”
*Nextdoor Neighborhood
"Fave - Favorite"
- Reviews from Customers -
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ “Real NY slices in Tampa!”
— Amanda R.
Closest I’ve had to a true NYC slice since moving to Florida. Thin, foldable, and super fresh. My new go-to for NY-style pizza
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ “Best Sicilian in Florida.”
— Marcus D
Their Sicilian is unreal — thick, crispy, and full of flavor. Worth the drive from Carrollwood every time.
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ “Perfect family spot.”
— Rachel M.
Great food, clean dining room, and fast service. The kids love the slices, and the pasta dinners are awesome. Best in Florida
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ “My favorite pizza in Carrollwood.”
— Jonathan B.
Finally found real NY pizza in Tampa. Always fresh, always consistent, and easy online ordering.
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ “Super consistent and delicious.”
— Stephanie K.
Every visit is great — hot, fresh, perfectly cooked pizza. Love the garlic knots and big pepperoni slices.
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ “Best pizza around.”
— Daniel F.
We order every week. Great slices, great Sicilian, great service. No other place compares not even in Brooklyn.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Where is Best NY Pizza located?
A: Best NY Pizza has two convenient Tampa Bay locations:
-
Carrollwood – 14741 N Dale Mabry Hwy, Tampa, FL 33618
-
Wesley Chapel – 27429 Wesley Chapel Blvd, Wesley Chapel, FL 33544
Q: Do you offer New York pizza in Wesley Chapel?
A: Yes! Our Wesley Chapel location serves the same authentic New York pizza Wesley Chapel customers enjoy, with both classic and creative toppings.
Q: Can I order online for pickup or delivery?
A: Yes. Both our Tampa and Wesley Chapel locations offer easy online ordering for pickup or delivery through our website.
Q: How long has Best NY Pizza been in business?
A: Since 2005, founded by Brooklyn natives Greg and Pat, we’ve been serving Tampa Bay the authentic taste of New York.
Q: What makes Best NY Pizza different from other pizzerias in Tampa?
A: We serve authentic NY-style pizza Tampa locals love, crafted from fresh, daily-made dough, premium mozzarella, and rich tomato sauce. Our stone-fired pizza Tampa Bay fans rave about is baked to perfection for the perfect crisp and flavor.
Q: Does Best NY Pizza offer catering?
A: Absolutely. We provide catering for events, parties, and corporate gatherings, offering pizza, pasta, salads, wings, and more.
Q: Do you have gluten-free or vegetarian options?
A: Yes. We offer gluten-free crusts and a variety of vegetarian pizzas and menu items to accommodate different dietary preferences.
Q: What else is on the menu besides pizza?
A: Our menu includes pasta, calzones, strombolis, subs, salads, and
appetizers, plus desserts and beverages.
We serve by the Slice & full Pizzas. Real Italian Diners. We offer dine in and Take out, we also deliver with DoorDash, Uber Eats, Grubhub
Real NY Style Pizza lives and dies by the crust. That’s why we do things the hard way:
-
Imported High-Gluten Flour: For that authentic strength and chew.
-
48-Hour Cold Proof: We let the flavor develop naturally over two days.
-
Hand-Stretched Daily: No rolling pins, no presses—just skilled hands.
-
Stone Deck Ovens: Baked hot and fast to lock in the crunch.
Taste the difference patience makes. Serving the crispest slices
Hand-Tossed. Stone-Baked. Never Rushed.
Best NY Pizza
Authentic New York-Style Pizza in Tampa & Wesley Chapel
Best NY Pizza serves authentic NY-style pizza Tampa loves and the New York pizza Wesley Chapel craves. We proudly serve communities across Tampa Bay with fast delivery services, takeout, and full catering services.
Founded in 2005 by Brooklyn natives Greg and Pat, Best NY Pizza uses fresh daily-made dough (hand-stretched from high-gluten flour), premium tomato sauce, high-quality cheeses, and top-tier ingredients for stone-fired pizzas with bold, authentic New York flavor.
Our menu features classic and specialty NY-style and Sicilian pizzas, plus Italian favorites like pasta, calzones, strombolis, subs, wings, salads, and appetizers—all in a welcoming, family-friendly setting.
Voted “Best Pizza in Tampa” by Creative Loafing and “Best Pizza in Tampa Bay” by the Tampa Bay Times, we stay true to our New York roots while offering custom options for local tastes.
New York-Style Pizza
New York-Style Pizza
Tampa & Wesley Chapel
Since 2005
Stone-Fired
Catering
Service Areas
Best NY Pizza proudly serves the following communities: New Tampa, Wiregrass, Seven Oaks, Pebble Creek, Northdale, Lake Magdalene, Egypt Lake-Leto, Carrollwood Village, Original Carrollwood, Plantation, Four Oaks, Carrollwood Cove, Forest Hills, Pinecrest West Park, Lowry Park Central, Seven Oaks, Meadow Pointe, Bridgewater, Estancia at Wiregrass, Esplanade at Wiregrass, Epperson Ranch, Country Walk, Chapel Pines, Avalon Park West, Lexington Oaks, Saddlebrook, The Ridge, Palm Cove, Watergrass, Chapel Crossings.
Italian Classics & Catering
Beyond pizza, we offer pasta, calzones, strombolis, subs, and catering—served in a welcoming, casual setting where customers feel like family.